OSHA Proposal Seeks to Place Union Reps on Non-Union Jobsites: Industry Pros Weigh In

Written by Todd Petrasic / October 17, 2024

*This article by Beth Miller features INSTALL executive director David Gross as an industry pro for Floor Trends Magazine.

OSHA Proposal Seeks to Place Union Reps on Non-Union Jobsites: Industry Pros Weigh In

Should union representatives be allowed to accompany federal safety inspectors on non-union employer’s jobsites? The U.S. Department of Labor issued a proposal in August 2023 titled the “Worker Walkaround Representative Designation Process.” The purpose of the proposal is to clarify who is eligible to accompany OSHA compliance officers during workplace inspections.

According to the proposal document (Docket No. OSHA–2023–00080), “OSHA is proposing to amend its Representatives of Employers and Employees regulation to clarify that the representative(s) authorized by employees may be an employee of the employer or a third party; such third-party employee representative(s) may accompany the OSHA Compliance Safety and Health Officer (CSHO) when they are reasonably necessary to aid in the inspection.”

The docket was open for comment submissions until October 30, 2023; however, many wrote in requesting a deadline extension of 60 days to December 31, 2023, to provide ample time to prepare and submit responses. The deadline was extended to November 13, 2023.

Responses are public information and can be found at regulations.gov with Docket No. OSHA–2023–00080. Over 11,000 public and private responses were submitted for and against the proposal.

Bill Cassidy, M.D., Ranking Member, Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions submitted a response opposing the ruling, “At issue is whether the employee representative must also be an employee; and, if employees are permitted to designate a third-party representative, whether that representative must offer expertise relevant to the inspection. The current regulation is clear that the employee representative must also be an employee of that employer ‘unless the OSHA inspector determines good cause for a third party to be present to conduct an effective examination of the workplace.’”

The Ohio Manufacturer’s Association finds issue with the language used to define those who are eligible to assist an OSHA compliance officer on the jobsite, “These changes do not make the workplace safer or healthier. They simply remove any qualifying barriers to who can traipse through a worksite. Permitting just about anyone to accompany an OSHA inspection would convert the inspection from being focused on workplace safety to being an organizing tact for unions, a litigation strategy for attorneys, and an opportunity to harass employers,” wrote James Lee, director of public policy.

We reached out to union and non-union flooring industry professionals, asking for their feedback on the proposal and how it will impact commercial projects going forward should it pass.

David Gross: Executive Director, International Training & Standards Alliance (INSTALL)

While there is much discussion and spotlighting on what the proposed rule change means in terms of union organizing, this focus misses the bigger question. Just who should be the employee’s representative in these inspection instances?

There was an interpretation issued in February of 2013 known as the “Fairfax Memo” that addressed this issue. When researching this subject more deeply one finds there is more than a union/non-union issue here. I would ask why the discussion is being framed as solely union based. It could be just as easy to bring in a third-party that is a competing business owner, lawyer, environmental group, or industrial hygienist.

Those that argue against this proposed rule change would like to see only an employee of the company be able to act as a walkaround representative of the company in the OSHA inspection process. However, that has its own pitfalls. Would the employee that relies on this employer for their livelihood be willing to properly address safety issues that may be present? How would the selection process of the employee representative be accommodated to assure of competency and impartiality. I believe this scenario is just as precarious as letting third-party entities be the accompaniment.

There is much to work out here. The development and clarification of OSHA regulations is a very laborious and time-consuming task when done correctly. OSHA is about worker safety and I have faith they will consider the many competing viewpoints to arrive at a conclusion. The more important issue is worker safety.

I can speak for INSTALL as a component of the United Brotherhood of Carpenters Union and say that we highly value worker safety. In the long run it is good business. We want our members to have long productive lives that allow them to enjoy the fruits of their labor. Our industry partners will benefit from lower insurance claims and costs along with an experienced workforce that capitalizes on longevity.

We appreciate the work that OSHA does and are interested in all workers—union or not—having the safest work environment possible. An employer that cuts corners on safety may think they are gaining a competitive advantage in saving money, but over time, the cost could be very significant in human tragedy.

Rod Von Busch: Vice President of Operations, C.D.I. Floors, and Advisory Board Chair, International Certified Flooring Installers (CFI) Advisory Board

The intent of this proposal is a complete mystery to me. What possible advantage does OSHA believe there might be? The only possible scenario, I can imagine short of some political motive, is to assist the OSHA inspectors in some training process. But frankly, if OSHA is incapable of properly training their personnel without the union involvement that’s a poor state of affairs. OSHA is supposed to be the experts when it comes to safety and jobsite hazards.

Our company has teamed with local OSHA on several occasions for education events, and I have always found their staff very knowledgeable. If the goal is to partner with the contract community, why would they not go directly to the specific jobsite safety personnel for the assistance? I doubt that the union representatives are any more qualified than the general contractor’s safety managers.

If assistance in training is not the case, then I would guess, this is just a political move. However, what do the unions have to gain? I don’t normally consider myself a conspiracy theorist, and I’m not anti-union. The only advantage I can see for the union to have a presence on non-union jobsites is to have contact with those non-union workers. I certainly hope this is not the case. But the fact that I or anyone would consider this as a motive for the unions’ involvement is good reason for OSHA to reconsider this proposal.

What is going to happen when the first non-union company calls foul claiming that they have been treated unfairly due to a union representative that is affiliated with one of their competitors influencing a OSHA’s jobsite review. Who ever dreamed up this idea, apparently doesn’t recognize how complicated navigating these issues could become.

Paul Stuart: Co-founder, Go Carrera, and President, Stuart & Associates Commercial Flooring

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration’s (OSHA) proposed rule change allows “third parties” to accompany OSHA on project inspections. The rule states: “The representatives authorized by employees may be an employee of the employer or a third party.” Proponents say it will make the workplace safer if the employees elect a third party to accompany OSHA on walkthroughs.

Employers have some rights when it comes to OSHA like having the ability to demand that OSHA obtain a warrant before conducting an inspection. This rule would have a unique and unclear effect on the construction industry. Contractors and specialty contractors often do not have property rights on the jobsites they perform at; thus, OSHA may not have to obtain a warrant as long as the building owner does not raise issue.

The main concern is that union reps may be able to visit non-union projects. The crux of the concern lies in the potential for union representatives to participate in safety inspections of non-union jobsites. Critics argue that such an arrangement would serve as a conduit for recruitment of non-union companies’ employees and further cause undue scrutiny on the contractors and subcontractors operating in a non-union environment.

Moreover, the ambiguity surrounding the employer’s rights to refuse union reps as a “third party” causes more uncertainty in the workplace particularly surrounding trade and operational secrets. This type of regulation could open Pandora’s box concerning the intentions of union reps and the resulting damage to non-union employers’ operations.

Another concern surrounds the liability of the third party should they be injured or cause injury to others while on site. It is unclear who would be liable in either of these events.

The industry awaits further clarification and guidance on how the changes may be implemented. We all want a safe working environment; however, the intentions must be aligned with workplace safety where the well-being of workers is paramount.

Explore More News from INSTALL

Factors to Consider in Substrate Prep

Read Article

OSHA Proposal Seeks to Place Union Reps on Non-Union Jobsites

Read Article

Moisture Testing and Control Advances Bring Need for New Training

Read Article

What INSTALL Warranty Contractor Designation Means

Read Article

Qualified Concrete Polishing Bridging Art, Science and Expertise

Read Article

Hardwood Floors Gain Bolder Design, Technical Advancements

Read Article

INSTALL Specification Resource for Floorcovering Installations

Read Article

Infection Prevention: Your Mission, Our Expertise

Read Article

INSTALL Connects the Best in the Flooring Industry

Read Article

Flooring Olympics Celebrates Skills & Positive Industry Outlook

Read Article

Subfloor Preparation Certification: What Installers Need to Know

Read Article

Alternative Career Pathways & Succession for Flooring Installers

Read Article

Avoid Costly Missteps in Subfloor Prep, Three Factors to Assess

Read Article

With Certification, the Floor is Yours

Read Article

How Education Can Help Recruit the Next Generation of Installers

Read Article

Engaging the Next Generation of Floorcovering Installers

Read Article

INSTALL Sponsors New Accredited Webinar With Architectural Record

Read Article

Partner News: December 2023

Read Article

How to Overcome the Challenges of Retaining Flooring Installers

Read Article

Building a Successful Business Through Effective Communication

Read Article

INSTALL Announces 2023 Drywall & Flooring Olympics Winners

Read Article

Partner News: October 2023

Read Article

INSTALL Joins Floor Trends Magazine's TalkFloor Podcast

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: February 2023

Read Article

Healthcare Certifications Are More Important Than Ever

Read Article

INSTALL Introduces New Executive Director David Gross

Read Article

The Retirement of INSTALL Executive Director John T. McGrath, Jr.

Read Article

How Installers Help Healthcare Facilities Prevent Costly Rework

Read Article

Why Proper Floor Covering Installation Training Is Vital

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: December 2022

Read Article

Top-Notch Floor Covering Training Adds Long-Term Value

Read Article

Tips to Solve Common LVT & LVP Installation Issues

Read Article

Proper Training Can Help Avoid Safety Risks for Occupants

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: August 2022

Read Article

New Resilient Flooring And Carpet Certification Standards

Read Article

INSTALL Announces New Alliance Partners

Read Article

INSTALL's Course Offerings Expand With Hardwood Flooring Training

Read Article

Training and Trust Help Flooring Installers Grow in New Markets

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: June 2022

Read Article

INSTALL Expands Apprenticeship Program to Support Industry Growth

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: April 2022

Read Article

Importance of Specifying UBC-ICRA Protocols in a Covid-19 World

Read Article

Understanding Flooring Moisture Mitigation

Read Article

Keeping INSTALL Inclusive

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: December 2021

Read Article

INSTALL and Teknoflor Join Efforts to Ensure Quality Installation

Read Article

M. Frank Higgins Introduced as Latest INSTALL Warranty Contractor

Read Article

INSTALL & Tarkett Partnership to Elevate Installation Standards

Read Article

INSTALL and H2H Help Veterans Transition to Civilian Life

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: November 2021

Read Article

XL North Interview With INSTALL's John T. McGrath, Jr.

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: June 2021

Read Article

How to Keep the Jobsite Safe amid COVID-19

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: April 2021

Read Article

Smith Flooring Inc. Selected as First Stop on Presidential Tour

Read Article

INSTALL & FCICA Work to Elevate Flooring Installation Standards

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: February 2021

Read Article

The Formula to Protecting Occupied Healthcare Facilities

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: December 2020

Read Article

INSTALL Inducts Five New Members to its Floorcovering Alliance

Read Article

Not a Flooring Fad: Polished Concrete & Pourable Wear Toppings

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: October 2020

Read Article

Five Best Practices for Specifying Flooring in a COVID-19 World

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: June 2020

Read Article

Polished Concrete Sets Foundation in Flooring

Read Article

Ensuring Employee Safety on the Jobsite During COVID-19

Read Article

M. Frank Higgins & Co., Inc. Hosts ICRA Training Program

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: April 2020

Read Article

Women Flooring Installers Help Solve the Labor Crisis

Read Article

Three Reasons to Hire Certified Floorcovering Installers

Read Article

Addressing the Deadly Threat of Silica

Read Article

INSTALL Welcomes New Members to Expansive Floorcovering Network

Read Article

Watch: Installers Lay Groundwork for Polished Concrete Flooring

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: February 2020

Read Article

The Impact of Technology on the Flooring Installation Industry

Read Article

INSTALL to Present at World of Concrete 2020 and DOMOTEX USA 2020

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: November 2019

Read Article

INSTALL Showcases ICRA Standards at 2019 APIC Expo

Read Article

Innovations that are Changing the Floorcovering Industry

Read Article

Image Flooring Partners with INSTALL to Expand

Read Article

INSTALL Continues Support for Helmets to Hardhats Partnership

Read Article

Polish Your Skills: The Latest in Concrete Polishing

Read Article

How to Increase Professionalism in Installation

Read Article

Four Ways to Become More Efficient on the Jobsite

Read Article

INSTALL Members Donate Time and Skills for Charity

Read Article

Putting Concrete Polishing Education Front and Center

Read Article

Meeting Infection Control Protocols in Healthcare Designs

Read Article

UBC Announces Leadership Changes, Reaffirms Commitment to INSTALL

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: July 2019

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: July 2019

Read Article

INSTALL Continues Increasing Availability of Formal Training

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: June 2019

Read Article

Floorcovering Industry Heightens Response to Skilled Labor Crisis

Read Article

Expansion Program Helps Image Flooring Grow throughout Midwest

Read Article

INSTALL Expands Partnership with Department of Veterans Affairs

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: May 2019

Read Article

ARDEX Americas supports INSTALL with Polished Toppings Training

Read Article

INSTALL Puts Finishing Touches on Concrete Polishing Curriculum

Read Article

Floorcovering's Commitment to Saving Lives in Healthcare

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: April 2019

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: April 2019

Read Article

The Rise of Concrete Polishing

Read Article

INSTALL to Present New ICRA CEU at 2019 AEC BuildTech Conference

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: March 2019

Read Article

INSTALL Introduces New Warranty Contractor and Alliance Partners

Read Article

Ambassador Floor Lends Efforts to Combat the Skilled Labor Crisis

Read Article

Alliance Partner News: February 2019

Read Article

Four Ways to Become a Better Installer

Read Article

Reviving the Skilled Labor Pipeline in the Floorcovering Industry

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: January 2019

Read Article

Engaging in a "People First" Model for Employee Retention

Read Article

2018 INSTALL Milestones: Flooring Trade Update

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: October 2018

Read Article

INSTALL Supports Veterans through Career Placement Program

Read Article

Earn CEU credits with INSTALL's new curriculum

Read Article

Don’t fear the future of the floor covering industry

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Penny Czarra

Read Article

INSTALL Conference brings collaboration to meet industry demands

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Frank Koch

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: July 2018

Read Article

INSTALL Expansion Initiative Steadily Progresses

Read Article

INSTALL & Roppe Partner at NeoCon 2018

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Mike Maguire

Read Article

Announcing new Alliance Partners and INSTALL Warranty Contractors

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Del Church

Read Article

New Texas Training Center celebrates grand opening

Read Article

Sisters in the Brotherhood Participate in New INSTALL Training

Read Article

Tarkett & INSTALL partner to create integrated education program

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Andy Bowman

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: February 2018

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Richard Schmidt

Read Article

Reduce Maintenance Costs with Polished Concrete Flooring

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: January 2018

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: James Colombo

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: December 2017

Read Article

Master Craft Flooring Wins 2017 FCI Installation Award

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: November 2017

Read Article

INSTALL Opens Enrollment for CIM Program Scholarship

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Michael Bonacci

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Adam Williams

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: October 2017

Read Article

INSTALL Sees Continued Growth in Southern U.S.

Read Article

INSTALL Announces Canadian NAC Winner

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Kelly Bakke

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: September 2017

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Jeff Johnson

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: August 2017

Read Article

INSTALL Combats Labor Shortage through Industry Partnerships

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: David Altman

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: July 2017

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Jeff Moore

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: June 2017

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Dan Solomon

Read Article

INSTALL & Partners to Host ICRA Training

Read Article

INSTALL & Roppe Partner at NeoCon 2017

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: May 2017

Read Article

INSTALL & H2H Partnership Reaches First Year Milestone

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Ron Zimmerman

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: April 2017

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Jim Wilkinson

Read Article

Laticrete Joins Endorsement of Substrate Prep Certification

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: March 2017

Read Article

INSTALL Included in Master Spec, Provides VA with Peace of Mind

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Heather Rice

Read Article

Why Moisture Testing is a Step that Can’t be Ignored

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: February 2017

Read Article

INSTALL Insights: Resilients

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Tom Sheridan

Read Article

Industry Leaders Endorse the INSTALL Substrate Prep Certification

Read Article

Flooring System Success: Get it Right from the Ground Up

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: January 2017

Read Article

INSTALL's Certified Installation Manager Scholarship Winner

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Tom Lutz

Read Article

INSTALL Takes on Installation’s Challenges

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: December 2016

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Brian Redshaw

Read Article

INSTALL & H2H Bring Veterans to the Flooring Industry

Read Article

INSTALL Insights: Selecting the Right Contractor

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Garrett Maki

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: October 2016

Read Article

Canadian National Apprenticeship Contest

Read Article

INSTALL Launches Substrate Certification Program

Read Article

INSTALL combats skilled labor crisis with training

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Kirk Kazienko

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: September 2016

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Laura Graham-Sawchyn

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: August 2016

Read Article

UBC Southern Council Collective Bargaining Agreement

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Bryan Kear

Read Article

This Month at INSTALL: July 2016

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: July 2016

Read Article

Consolidated Carpet Supports St. Francis Pantries & Shelters

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Barb Kidwell

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: June 2016

Read Article

VA Taps INSTALL for Master Construction Specification

Read Article

INSTALL Recap: NeoCon 2016

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: Eric Kastner

Read Article

INSTALL Partners with BHI for Haiti Build

Read Article

INSTALL Launches Surface Prep Certification

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: May 2016

Read Article

INSTALL Regional Council News: April 2016

Read Article

INSTALL Profile: David Gross

Read Article

2016 Starnet Design Awards

Read Article

INSTALL Expands Training in Central South Market

Read Article

INSTALL Director's Report: April 2016

Read Article

Substrate and Subfloor Installations for High-Quality Flooring

Read Article

VIDEO: The INSTALL Expansion Partnership Program

Read Article

VIDEO: The INSTALL Advantage

Read Article